| News Blog |
"Inconvenient Truth" In Geography Class
A movie that divided a nation is being shown in a 6th grade geography class at Rock Lake Middle School in Seminole County. Many parents are not happy about that. Dr. Charyl Tabscott began showing Al Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth" to her class on Monday. The remainder of the film is scheduled to be screened Wednesday.
The documentary claims man is responsible for global warming. Those claims have yet to be proven by science. One mother said she's not sure such a controversial topic belongs in a geography class.
"It bothers me because I have the feeling the kids are only hearing Al Gore's side of the story. I think what he's saying is really inconvenient, but it's not the whole truth."
What do you think? Comment below
What others are saying
- You're RightYou're right it is just a movie, with no scientific proof according to scientists, so why show it? To promote a political view point! I think we all need to snap out of it and stop letting the politicians led us around by the nose with their scare tactics and hidden agendas! Republicans and Democrats alike! Has Al Gore stopped jetting around the world to help his cause? It's esy to climb on a soap box, but changing your lifestyle is a little inconvenient for Mr. Gore!
- Behind the curve on this oneAll of the global warming doomsayers are behind the curve. More recent science suggests that sunspot activity has more to do with global warming than man's activities - see http://www.ibdeditorials.com/IBDArticles.aspx?id=293843193434228 and http://www.spaceweather.com/. Indeed these more recent studies suggest that we are out of a global warming period and going into a cooling trend. Please note that China just had the worst winter in more than a century. Quebec had their worst winter in decades. One should do some research and not buy hook line and sinker the arguments of those who stand to gain by global warming hysteria (indlucing Al Gore, who chairs a company that sells carbon credits).
- Parents...this is why you need to be involved...in your child's education. This is one viewpoint of some controversial science funded by people who have a political agenda (no matter how environemntally conscious they claim to be). It's your job to help present the other side of the story. Don't leave it up to the schools to educate your children. That is the philosophy that is killing this country!
The environmental agenda is a ruse for reintroducing socialism. This presents one viewpoint of data interpreted from computer models. Learn the facts for yourselves parents, and help educate your children. That is your job, not the school's! Yes the school is there to help, but only to help. - Then how about Ben Stein's movie?I don't have a problem with students watching this movie, if they are taught to think about what they are watching. I agree with other comments here that we need to teach our kids how to think more critically and use deductive reasoning more. Although I don't necessarily agree with Al Gore's movie, I think that it may be a useful tool to help our kids think about the world in which we live and the effects of our consumerism. I also think another movie that could possibly be shown to high school students is Ben Stein's movie, Expelled, which talks about intelligent design versus evolution. Again, lets teach our kids how to critically think about the world around them and not accept everything at face value.
- Schools are meant to teach FACTS. Even Mr Gore does not belive in global warming, if he did, he would practice what he preaches.
- Finally, a teacher who is trying to make kids think!I applaud the teacher for showing the movie. It's a movie...a movie, for goodness sake....It's Earth Week. the children actually have a chance to think for a change. No child is harmed by watching a movie about global warming..good grief, get over it...let the teachers broaden the children's mind...If you want to get angry about the school system, let's rally together about how stupid our children are becoming because our wonderful teachers are forced to teach to the FCAT!
- "Inconvenient Truth" In Geography ClassThat teacher should be FIRED!Political views SHOULD not be taught in the classroom. Teachers are not allowed to teach their religious views, SO then why are they allowed to teach political views? Seems like a double standard to me!
- snap out of it!!!I am appalled by the negative comments made earlier in this thread.. They are so clearly political in tone and completely oblivious to the FACT that we are in a serious state of distress. This is not a political issue. This is a global environmental issue that can only be dealt with if the YOUNGER generation is made aware of it. I welcome this teacher showing this film, and I welcome the scientific and analytical viewpoints that are shown in this movie. Forget about who made it.. That makes zero difference. period. Oh and by the way its called "geography" class. Its a class where children and teachers discuss the land and the human and environmental impact on land. GEOGRAPHY! your generation has ignored these problems long enough and these things are most definitely worth discussing right now. and another thing.. This generation's oblivious mindset is what got us in this mess to begin with. Its clearly time to embrace the issues at hand and instead of bickering about who says what. Those concerns have no place here... most of your hero's have even recognized this... Get with it.
- Inconvenient TruthAntarctica is a part of geography class, and the study of Global Warming is certainly a topic that fits within the curriculum in the State of Florida. The film presents research for students to analyze. Educators must teach students to engage their intelligent minds. The exploration of this relevant topic is critical for children who are our future. Support for teachers who are executing the curriculum should be commended. Thank you to teachers who dedicate their professional lives to our future. It is a shame we don't recognize their service and praise them more often.
- AlgoreWhat numbers equal the number 4? You can ONLY get the answer by adding 2 + 2......welcome to our school system. Our children lose, and most of all our so called teachers are to blame for not teaching both sides, they are the REAL losers! My grandchildren are getting BOTH sides to any issue.
- Are you kidding me?Brainwash, brainwash, brainwash! This is ridiculous! Global warming is going to be taught just like evolution...that it's fact and accept it. Both sides are never represented anymore and it's time people stand up! This film should not be shown in a middle school. It's not objective and filled with fluffy facts. This teacher should be ashamed of herself.
- Ludicrous!These kids are too young to be seeing this film. Can you say 'indoctrination?!' Politics don't belong in school, much less a teacher trying to push their views on innocent children!
advertisement
Marketplace
Stay healthy thanks to Dr. Susan Mitchell's Nutrition and Health Center! Get recipes, hear internet shows, and much more!
Learn how to create your ideal living space. After all... It's YOUR Home!
Welcome to the Boating and Fishing Guide - Central Florida's source for boating and fishing information. Drop a line here!
Get information and professional advice in many categories, from health to home improvement! Ask the Experts!
AM580 WDBO encourages you to help the environment and Go Green! Use our tips!
advertisement
Stay ahead of the storm. Find evacuation routes, safety tips and more in the Hurricane Guide .
Don't miss your favorite TV shows! Click to get the latest WFTV Channel 9 programming schedule.




